Whirlguy's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Vindaloo]

You improved greatly

I love this song! Its simple yet really effective, and sounds really proffesional. You improoved greatly since my last review too! Your more quality and equalizement:3 I love those percursions, I adore them! And that funny melody playing through everytime. What was that instrument called anyway? Sorry.. I always get confused with asian instruments hehe.. Anyway:
OR: 10, I loved the vocals in this one haha! And who on newgrounds would think of making an Indian song?
DI: 8, There wasnt alot, but it wasnt boring me at all anyway.
CL: 10, You improved greatly on this(:
EF: 10, I would say so.. Quality product!
OV: 10, yush I love it!

LimblessAvenger responds:

there is so much wrong with this review:
1: proffessional = PROFESSIONAL
2: improoved = IMPROVED
3: "Your more quality and equalizement" = ?
4: asian instruments: no! Indian instruments. i think its a Santoor
5: yush

[this gravity]

I dont review alot nowadays

I like this one, easygoing guitarplaying in the beginning, The effects made it sound like bad quality, but it fooled me. The drums surprised me, cool a switch, and groovy too! Great how it goes along together too. I love it this far. At this point I read about vox, I wondered what that would sound like. And then it started, really good. I mean, sometimes its hard to think of what way to add vox, and this was good(: Good way of keeping interest, Yeah^^
OR: 10, I like the subject, also the style^^
DI: 9, I like it^^
CL: 8, pretty good, I think it could be better though
EF: 8, Good work
OV: 9, Like it alot^^ Im not sure about the equalizing though, might make the kick a bit more powerfull.

snoballandthmonyshot responds:

yo whirlygig,
glad u enjoyed the track and the transition... vox, yeh, is difficult... i may have a different standpoint to a lot of peple... all of my vox are purely functional, i generally don't like the sound of my voice and therefore only use it when i feel it's needed and try and twist it so it's relevant and adds to a track rather than using it as a focal point.
whatever, thanks for listening
;ped

[(_RGH_) Spring Daze(Days)]

Hello^^

Great track! I dont have to tell you about the diversity anymore, its just perfect as ever. I loved the climax part, it was so soothing yet powerfull. It really made me wuzzy in my head. I also loved the synth after that part, it was just an awesome fit! Just one little thing that was a bother, the hi-hat was just a bit too high frequenced. But yup, Im envious afterall hehe
OR: 10, nice inspirationsource^^
DI: 10, you're just too good at this! Maybe you give me some hints.. ^^; awesome job!
CL: 9, Oh, come to think of it.. There was this part where a kick came in. Maybe that one was a little too loud..
EF: 10, deserved mister!
OV: 9, Not a perfectly scored 10, butit was reeeaaaly close to it^^ Rank 2 on my favourite artist list^^

RyeGuyHead responds:

Thank you whirlguy, i would be glad to give you any tips

[(_RGH_) The Tribe is Among Us]

O_O WOW

Dude.. Im.. FUCKING AMAZED!! The way of composing, the clarity, the use of samples.. Everything! Just wow.. You deserved straight tens from me for the first time, keep this up seriously! But I can not leave this review with satisfaction before I get a somewhat bigger description of the progress:3 So please tell me in the responce^^
OR: 10, the Idea was cool, I wonder what inspired you(:
DI: 10, You always do such amazing jobs on composing..
CL: 10, Just WOW on the samples. Did you go to africa and came back with some tribemen??!?
EF: 10, Great effort! When I hear this I feel like I am a lame artist, a failure): But Ill push through(:

OV: 10, This is my favourite of yours for now, I am amazed:D

RyeGuyHead responds:

Thank you very much Whirlguy, hearing frm you always makes me happy,
The samples are all pretty much standard of reason 3.0, I just meshed them together to get my desired sound.

Inspiration came from playing alot of WoW through my tauren character.

You are not a lame artist

[Majora's Mask - Oath to Order]

Swamp. Mountain. Ocean. Canyon. Hurry...

Wow! Using the guitar for this song is the best! You go Mikau! Coolest would have been if you used all the instrument: ocarina, guitar pipes and drums.. Wouldnt have sound as good as this tho:P
OR: 8, this made me realize something. I LOOVE this song, but I never heared a remix of this song before..
DI: 10, hmmn yes, you could have put in some improvising parts of piano(that what i wouldve done to make it longer).. heheh makes me think of the mask man:P
CL: 8, at the beginning of the electric guitar it begins to sound weird and I hear sounds that you probably did not even put in the songO_o
EF: 8, Nonetheless great effort.
OV: 8, I wouldve liked some improvising, thats all

ZombiePosessor responds:

Great review! Thanks!

[EarthBound - Hospital]

Didnt leave a review for a while

Yes i didnt.. I watched you tho. And ive seen reviews of some bigger names of the ng audio portal, youre doing very well already(: I heared this remix of you before, and this is the reason im playing this game again:P
OR 6: Earthbound isnt that original, although there arent that many remixes for a game this old..
DI 7: Not amazing, mostly because you just copied the original, and of course, the ending couldve been better.
CL 10: equzalizing is good and it sounds clear, i really like the sound of the drums and bass.. well everything:P
EF 9: You often just end it. Is it because the filsize is already too big, or dont you have a clue to end it? You could always just try to loop it(:
OV 7: I liked it, yes it is one of the best rpg's. THe thing is, there is so much mroe nice sounding music in this game.. Im hoping for another earth bound remix(:

ZombiePosessor responds:

About the ending to the song, this was before I either faded out or looped my songs, so thats the explanation for that. I'll def be doing more EB tunes. There's a bunch already on my website if you wanna check em out. http://zombie.blackzero.net

[Zelda: Minish Cap - Cloud Tops]

great way of brining this theme!

You know... i thought te latest zelda's their music didnt really sound as magical as they used to sound. But you made this song sound more like the compositions of ocarina of time, and that really makes me like this song. I also love the use of timpanis, gives it alot of power, the snair roll however, was a bit weird, and made it sound a bit fake. The equzalizing was a bit off too, however, this song cant be THAT old.
OR 9: yeah its getting a bit less original
DI 8: Nice parts so now and then, but still i dont like the ending.
CL 7: The equalizing again.
EF 8: Equzlizing and effort lack, however the compostition and the way of bringing it were great!
OV 7: Great song

ZombiePosessor responds:

Actually, I didn't know much about Equalizing when I made this one, lol. Thanks for the review.

[LoZ: OOT - Gerudo Valley]

Best version ive ever heared

Why? Because im sick of the improvising to this song. This version displayed its true origin. And i can remember those days playing zelda.. And this magical song played; Gerudo Valley. Im trully sttisfied with this version. just hoped to hear more accoustic, and thats why i didnt really like the electric guitar, aw well..
OR 4: This song has been done ALOT
DI 10: Like
CL 9: Like this too, just the electric guitar didnt fit the relaxing mood it gave me.
EF 10: Using the electric guitar was a good way to keep the diversity. Think ill have to count that with effort.
OV 10: a ten because this is the best version i know of this song.

ZombiePosessor responds:

Nice, I love how you review songs. Thanks.

[Ragnarok Online - Streamside]

RO goodness!

Ha! Thats the best RO song! I must admit you have style. You coppied this one very well! But still the samples didn really work that nicely, maybe some more reverb, to make it all echoey. The panning however is fantastic, and the playing is precisely the same. I just hoped i would get the same peacefull feeling as when ever i play this game..
OR 10: You dont see RO songs everyday..
DI 10: Just as good as the original
CL 7: Aw well, the equalizing wasnt that great, and the volume at some parts was a bit too loud
EF 8: However, the effort was huge(:
OV 9: As i said before, equalizing is the key to the top!(: And congrats, nobody never made me write 3 reviews on a day + another one of someone elseO_o

ZombiePosessor responds:

Haha, cool, thanks man. Yeah, the EQ was bad on this one (another old one) and when I'd hit the chords on the guitar some of em were too loud. But I'd worked on that one all day and didn't feel like fixing it, lol. You should check out my other RO song. I'm halfway working on the Prontera theme.

[LoZ: Minish Cap - Village]

Awesome!

AWESOME! Dude, i didnt think there would be many other remixes of LOZTMC than mine on newgrounds! This one kicks ass, im putting your page in my favourites, so i can check once in a while!(: THeres nothing really to comment on this time. I just love this songXD Thank you for making my day:P
OR 10: Remix or not, i dont hear TMC songs alot(:
DI 10: Yeah.. dont ask me why:P
CL 10: Nothing wrong with this, very good!
EF 10: Sounds precisely like the original, only in real music(:
OV 10: Only kingbastard/Monkeybullman(both pages deleted because he had too many downratersD:< ) was able to get a ten from me. I think there are many oher songs of yours that deserve a score of ten. I should listen to them all! But i do that some other time. I do suggest you to post your new songs in the audio advertisements in the audio forum. Becuase you should be known better on ng(:

ZombiePosessor responds:

Thanks man! I didn't know there was an audio advertisements forum lol. I'll do that from now on. Thanks a lot!